Legislative Update

Several states now have anti-MOC legislation pending.

Recently the Georgia legislature passed HB 165, similar to Oklahoma’s SB 1148, which prohibits Maintenance of Certification (MOC) as a condition of licensure or reimbursement from third parties. However, the ABMS and its member boards have been heavily lobbying state legislators to defeat the pending bills. Those of us opposed to MOC must educate the legislators in these states regarding how MOC requirements are onerous, expensive, have no proven benefit, and are forced on physicians by conflicted, self-appointed private ABMS member boards.

DATESTATEBILL NUMBERSTATUS SOURCE LINK
7/1/17Georgia State LegislatureHB165Passed (Strong)legis.ga.gov
1/1/18Texas State LegislatureSB1148Passed (Strong)legiscan.com
4/9/18Tennessee State LegislatureHB1927Passed (Strong)legiscan.com
4/11/18OklahomaSB1148Passed (Strong)legiscan.com
12/27/18Michigan State LegislatureHB4135Passed (Strong)legislature.mi.gov
3/15/18South Carolina LegislatureHB4116Passed (Weak)scstatehouse.gov
12/17/17Washington StateHB2257Passed (Weak)app.leg.wa.gov
7/1/16ArizonaHB2502Passed (Weak)legiscan.com
10/1/16North CarolinaHB728Passed (Weak)ncleg.net
3/16/16KentuckySB17Passed (Weak)legiscan.com
6/13/17MaineLD1200Passed (Weak)legiscan.com
3/10/18New HampshireHB1769Pendinggencourt.state.nh.us
2/12/18IndianaSB0208Pendingiga.in.gov
3/2017Rhode IslandHB5671Pendingstatus.rilin.state.ri.us
1/9/18New YorkS7357Pendingnysenate.gov
3/5/18New JerseyS2141Pendingnjleg.state.nj.us
3/16/18MarylandHB0857Pendingmgaleg.maryland.gov

Advocacy Materials

The following are instructions to help you make the best use of the NBPAS anti-MOC advocacy materials.

Legislative Materials

NBPAS Legislative Advocacy PowerPoint Presentation

This is a short slide deck intended for use with legislators and other non-medical stake holders. It defines some of the basic anti-MOC issues and makes a strong argument against MOC. It is designed for a small or large meeting with state representative.

Note: Some slides may need you to “click” to display all the animations. The commentary version’s slides have a small “speaker” icon in the lower right corner. If you click on the “play” icon, you will hear Dr. Teirstein commenting on the specific slide. The comments are designed to help explain the slide and enhance your understanding of the material.

Download:

NBPAS Legislative Talking Points Handout

This is a PDF document that duplicates the above PowerPoint presentation. It can be handed out instead of the PowerPoint if a computer presentation is not practical and/or left with the stakeholder after your meeting.

Download:

AMA Model Legislation

Download:

Hospital Advocacy Materials

NBPAS Hospital Advocacy PowerPoint Presentation

This is a comprehensive presentation designed for a hospital grand rounds or MEC presentation.

Note: Some slides may need you to “click” to display all the animations. The commentary version’s slides have a small “speaker” icon in the lower right corner. If you click on the “play” icon, you will hear Dr. Teirstein commenting on the specific slide. The comments are designed to help explain the slide and enhance your understanding of the material.

Download:

Videos and References

Annotated Reference List

This list provides links to key publications relating to MOC. It is NOT intended to be exhaustive, rather it contains enough material for you to be comfortable presenting some of the primary data. Each entry has a description of the publication’s key points.

Download:

Annotated Reference List (.pdf – 79KB)

Video of Dr. Teirstein’s Side of Debate Against the CEO of the ABMS (30min)

A 30 minute video of Dr. Teirstein’s side of a debate against the CEO of the ABIM and the CEO of the ABIM at the Fall 2015 meeting of the Association of Professor’s in Medicine. This video also contains much of the PowerPoint in #3 above and will provide some context that may aid in your own presentation.

Video of Dr. Teirstein’s Side of Debate Against the CEO of the ABMS (14 min)

A 14 minute video of Dr Teirstein’s side of a debate against the CEO of the ABMS at the fall meeting of the California Medical Association: This video contains much of the PowerPoint in #3 above and will provide some context that may aid in your own presentation.

NBPAS and Anti-MOC News

Please also look at the News page of NBPAS.org for more academic and lay press articles about MOC.